Fourth lawsuit makes 20 workers alleging a poisonous tradition throughout the DC police division
Three of the 5 workers beforehand labored within the police division’s Equal Employment Alternative unit, which is accountable for investigating claims of discrimination filed by sworn officers and civilians on the MPD. Two nonetheless work within the division.
Thursday’s lawsuit particulars complaints made by counselors who labored underneath Alphonso Lee, the director of the EEO division on the MPD. Pamela Keith, one of many attorneys on all 4 lawsuits, advised CNN that’s telling.
“I’ve by no means seen a case the place all 5 workers of an EEO Division are primarily claiming collusion to violate somebody’s civil rights,” Keith mentioned. “The entire division is telling the identical story.”
Lee declined to touch upon the fourth go well with and its allegations, deferring to the MPD. He isn’t referenced within the different three lawsuits. In response to a touch upon the most recent lawsuit, the MPD advised CNN they can not focus on the allegations on account of pending litigation. In addition they mentioned they “take these allegations critically” and “will likely be reviewing them totally and responding accordingly.” The MPD gave the identical response concerning the primary and third lawsuits and by no means commented on the second.
The 5 EEO staffers be part of a rising variety of workers who’ve made a variety of complaints towards the division. A complete of 20 plaintiffs — together with greater than a dozen Black girls officers alleging racial and sexual discrimination and a tradition of intimidation — are concerned in all of the lawsuits containing allegations towards the MPD. And the allegations of misconduct, discrimination and inappropriate habits have come from officers of all ranks: from recruits to prime brass.
What does this new lawsuit allege?
Every plaintiff within the fourth lawsuit has accused Lee of retaliating towards them for “reporting and opposing illegal, unethical, noncompliant, discriminatory and retaliatory actions,” the lawsuit states. Two of the plaintiffs additionally allege discrimination based mostly on race and gender.
The lawsuit alleges that Lee gave solely himself the authority to treatment and negotiate EEO disputes and managed investigations to “make sure that MPD administration was not harmed or embarrassed” by any of the claims. Based on the plaintiffs, Lee would make them rewrite stories that “painted administration in a unfavourable mild.”
It says the plaintiffs assume Lee acted as a “defender of MPD administration, put in place to undermine and discredit complainants, moderately than to analyze or treatment alleged acts of discrimination, or to implement the EEO rights of MPD workers.”
“The EEO Division is meant to be investigating in a impartial and unbiased manner,” Keith advised CNN, including that Lee required all the advisors to report each criticism and he typically performed these recordings for the folks whom the complaints have been towards. Additionally it is referenced within the criticism.
Based on the go well with, informing the goal of a criticism then led to retaliation towards the complainants by their superiors and friends.
Harry Carter, who was an EEO Counselor from February 2020 till December of that very same yr, says he was fired after reporting to the administration his issues about how the EEO workers was being handled and managed. The go well with claims he was fired not on account of efficiency, “however moderately in retaliation for Dir. Lee’s notion that Plaintiff Carter had betrayed him.”
Carter beforehand held the place of director of EEO Packages on the Naval Air Techniques Command for about 12 years, based on the go well with.
The go well with additionally says regardless that “dozens of complaints towards him have been filed throughout his tenure as EEO director,” no motion has been taken to self-discipline Lee, appropriate his actions or change EEO practices.
It additionally accuses the MPD of violating the DC Whistleblower Safety Act, retaliation based mostly on constructive discharge and violation of the Civil Rights Act of 1967 on account of gender and race discrimination, amongst others.
The plaintiffs are searching for compensation and alter throughout the EEO Division on the MPD. They need Lee to be relieved of his duties as EEO director, an “impartial Particular Grasp to conduct an intensive forensic audit” of the division and proposals to deliver the unit “into compliance with EEOC laws and finest practices,” based on the go well with.
Division management has not publicly mentioned the instances. Nevertheless, allegations from the 4 lawsuits have been mentioned Thursday throughout a Judiciary and Public Security Committee efficiency oversight listening to for the MPD. Charles Allen, a DC councilman, chaired the listening to.
“MPD as an establishment isn’t delivering on the promise of change and police reform,” Allen mentioned Thursday.
A number of of the plaintiffs, together with Carter, additionally testified in the course of the listening to, detailing how they have been handled by division management. Carter referred to as the division’s EEO program “the worst, most corrupt” he has ever skilled.
“The issue is that no person in administration desires to personal fixing this — not the police, not the mayor and never the Metropolis Council,” lawyer Keith advised CNN.
Neither Mayor Muriel Bowser’s workplace nor the DC Police Union have responded to CNN’s requests for feedback.
The DC Police Union has but to difficulty a press release in help of any of the plaintiffs, chairman Gregg Pemberton mentioned in the course of the efficiency oversight listening to.
Lee’s present standing is unclear. Keith says he’s nonetheless EEO director. Lee responded to CNN’s request for remark in an electronic mail with a signature that also lists his place as director of the EEO Division.
“The Chief can act right now, as a substitute of letting these instances wind by means of the courts, and the Division must publicly present it takes the allegations critically,” Allen advised CNN on Friday.
Every of those lawsuits appears at a special part of the MPD alleging a poisonous office and tradition that makes it onerous to query authority and attend work on daily basis.
The second lawsuit was filed a few month later by three Black girls who’re former members of the MPD Cadet Program, which gives coaching and expertise in regulation enforcement to potential police recruits. Their go well with alleges that the MPD is conscious front-line supervisors abuse their energy to “harass, isolate, intimidate, bully and denigrate Cadets.”
Keith advised CNN she is simply scratching the floor, as she is receiving calls from MPD detectives and investigators additionally alleging a “hostile work surroundings” and different types of “discrimination.”
Keith additionally testified throughout Thursday’s listening to and proposed options to the issues and allegations introduced forth within the lawsuits. She urged for the Workplace of Human Proper’s finances to be dramatically elevated, so that each officer who seeks promotability should have a rating based mostly on a random pattern of the folks they work together with, thus inflicting motivation to deal with everybody equally and pretty. She additionally recommends the EEO Division and IAD to be moved out from underneath the management of the chief of police.